If the inner motivations and traits of the agent for evaluating an action were considered, then selfeffacement would be seemingly avoided. Till now aristotle has been the principal focus of new interest in virtue ethics, but it is. Consequentialist, deontic, or virtue ethical views reveal different moral issues. Virtue in epistemology in recent years virtue theory has not only undergone a resurgence in ethical. If it sounds too good to be true, thats because it probably is. This paper proposes such a decision support system to assist in ethical decision making.
According to manias 20, virtue ethics is considered at times an agent based or character ethics. A virtue ethical account of right action christine swanton jstor. An agent based account of right action as we will see, p1, the agentbased account, is problematic that it pays no attention to the distinction between act from virtue and virtuous act and it might not satisfy the claim that virtue ethics needs an account of right action that is action guiding. While some varieties may escape this problem agentbased virtue theories in particular, the moral theory as a whole suffers alongside alternative moral theories. A right act is the action a virtuous person would do in the same circumstances. According to manias 20, virtue ethics is considered at times an agentbased or character ethics. Agentbased accounts of virtue ethics, such as the one provided by michael slote, base the rightness of action in the motive from which it. Based virtue ethics, midwest studies in philosophy. Three ethical approaches based on virtue, duty and. Businesses are completely incompatible with virtue ethics. A new form of agentbased virtue ethics springerlink.
One of the problems any such approach faces is to capture the commonsense distinction between an agents doing the right thing, and her doing it. Communicating bad news business for the glory of god. Against agentbased virtue ethics brady philosophical papers. View agent based virtue ethics research papers on academia. Based virtue ethics and the problem of action guidance. Deontology or deontological ethics is the branch of ethics in which people define what is morally right or wrong by the actions themselves, rather than referring to the consequences of those actions, or the character of the person who performs them. As in ethics, the aretaic turn in epistemology has. Business ethics is concerned with how well a business treats its stakeholders and whether a businesss actions are seen as ethical. Conceived of as a contender to other theories in substantive ethics, virtue ethics is often associated with, in essence, the following account or criterion of right action. Highlights i develop a framework for acknowledging and dealing with moral issues in modeling. Critics have claimed that slotes view and agentbased views more generally cannot account for several basic tenets of commonsense morality. There are at least four different types of actionguiding objections to an ethical theory.
Information technology and organizational innovation. Brady, against agentbased virtue ethics philpapers. One of the problems any such approach faces is to capture the commonsense distinction between an agent s doing the right thing, and her doing it. The more specific term computer ethics has been used, in the past, in several different ways. Journal of moral philosophy journal of moral philosophy 6 2009 5069. If the problems are varied, we should not expect to find their solution in one rigid. Virtue ethics paper term paper term paper warehouse. Forms of virtue ethics agent based or exemplarist virtue ethics agentbased virtue ethicists argue that forms of normavityincluding the value of eudaimonia are traced back to and ul. An intrinsic characteristic to any method of experimentation, within the eld of nlp and without, is to adhere to a morally and legally appropriate framework embedded in ethics. When faced with an ethical problem, one can consult a software package for guidance in making an ethical decision. Agent based ethics, conversely, argues that rightness of an action depends only on the motivations of the agent, and actions become virtuous on the basis of the virtuousness expressed by the agent in order to commit the act source.
There are serious objections to vr, which take the form of counterexamples. Contemporary virtue ethics agentbased virtue ethics. Computer and information ethics stanford encyclopedia of. Then i want to briefly outline the theory of one very prominent contemporary virtue ethicist. Virtue ethics belongs to the branch of philosophy called ethics. In particular, the critics maintain that agentbased theories. One of its chief proponents offers an agentbased virtueethical account that aspires to derive all moral value, including the moral status of actions, solely. In other words virtue ethics emphasizes one moral character. Virtue ethics and its potential as the leading moral theory. May 12, 2016 ethics is a key component of good governance perry et al.
Virtue ethics the basic assumption of virtue ethics is that professional ethics involve more than moral actions. Dec 10, 2019 while traditional virtue ethics focused on the virtues, modern virtue ethics take on an agentbased approach where motives are the primary concern bessant 430. One of the problems any such approach faces is to capture the commonsense distinction between an agent s doing the right thing, and her doing it for the. Virtue theory is composed of three main ideas eudemonism, agent based theories, and the ethics of care. Principle ethics and virtue ethics flashcards quizlet. Virtue ethics and its potential as the leading moral. Eudemonism is based in reasoning, agentbased theories are based in common sense and intuition, and ethics of care is solely based on justice and it should be noted as a primarily feminist idea.
It believes that an action is right if and only if it is what a virtuous agent would. One, the agentbased model of virtuous practi cal reasoning turns out to require precisely the sorts of deliberations that it professes to reject in the more aristotelian model. Linda radzik department of philosophy in his nicomachean ethics, aristotle introduces the concept of virtue, states of character that allow an agent to perform her function well, and gives a practical account of how someone can become virtuous. Mar 04, 2018 an explanation of two different theories of agent centered virtue ethics. Virtue theory is composed of three main ideas eudemonism, agentbased theories, and the ethics of care. The agentbased approach journal of business ethics and organization studies john dobson, california polytechnic state university san luis obispo. Liezl van zyl 2009 journal of moral philosophy 6 1. Virtue ethics and the search for an account of right action. Thus, the issue no longer revolves around whether or not an intention is right or wrong, but on whether or not the person acting is expressing good charactermoral virtues or not. Contemporary virtue ethics and actionguiding objections. An explanation of two different theories of agent centered virtue ethics.
Agentbased virtue ethics and the fundamentality of virtue. Moral midlevel principles in modeling sciencedirect. Contemporary defenders of virtue ethics often respond to this particular problem by. Agentbased virtue ethics avoids the circularity problem by defining right action in terms of virtuous motive, and then taking virtue as fundamental, as intrinsically and. Virtue ethics offers an account of right and wrong based on what a virtuous agent would do. These include how virtues are acquired, how they are applied in various real. Virtue ethics is also a sub branch of normative ethics and it contrasts with disteleology because normative ethics is more concerned about characteristics of a person rather than the moral duties and laws they must abide, so natural moral law, kantian ethics and divine command are usually dismissed by virtue ethics. Two, although agentbased virtue ethics could be modified to allow that model of. Jul 23, 2010 in morals from motives, michael slote defends an agentbased theory of right action according to which right acts are those that express virtuous motives like benevolence or care. Sep 25, 2008 consequentialism says that right or wrong depend on the consequences of an act, and that the more good consequences are produced, the better the act. In addition, we have seen how virtue ethics suffers from indeterminacy as it fails to be actionguiding. Contemporary virtue ethics, philosophy compass 11 january 2006. The trouble with flourishing is that animals and even plants can.
Agentbased virtue ethics is a unitary normative theory according to which the moral status of actions is entirely dependent upon the moral status of an agents motives and character traits. Lastly, the ability to cultivate the right virtues will be affected by a number of different factors beyond a persons control due to education, society. Jun 25, 2019 deontology is thus a theory of moral obligation, and it encompasses moral theories that emphasize a persons rights and duties. Aug 11, 2009 conceived of as a contender to other theories in substantive ethics, virtue ethics is often associated with, in essence, the following account or criterion of right action. Virtue ethics is currently one of three major approaches in normative ethics. Agent based virtue ethics is a unitary normative theory according to which the moral status of actions is entirely dependent upon the moral status of an agent s motives and character traits. What is michael slotes distinction between agentbased. An agent based focus on what one ought to be, in contrast to an action based focus on how one ought to act, would look carefully at a persons moral. Against agentbased virtue ethics brady philosophical. Based virtue ethics, midwest studies in philosophy 10. Agentbased virtue ethics strives to offer a viable account of both moral conduct and the source of moral value, independent of deontic teleological and deontological characterizations. Edmund pincoffs ethics theory presents the best model to use in this scenario. Act as a virtuous person would act in your situation.
It has been accepted for inclusion in walden dissertations and doctoral studies by an. The bibles teaching on the moral goodness of business business human rights. Two, although agent based virtue ethics could be modified to allow that model of. Applying virtue ethics to business the agent based.
A virtue ethicist is likely to give you this kind of moral advice. The differences connect to consequences of use, intentions, and questions elucidated. Agent based virtue ethics avoids the circularity problem by defining right action in terms of virtuous motive, and then taking virtue as fundamental, as intrinsically and 4 on virtue ethics oxford university press, 1999. It is also commonly held that an ethics of virtue can have little or nothing to say about issues involving the need for action guidance. In morals from motives, michael slote defends an agentbased theory of right action according to which right acts are those that express virtuous motives like benevolence or care. The following problem arises in hursthouses notion of rightness. Agentbased virtue ethics strives to offer a viable account of both moral conduct and. Virtue ethics and the search for an account of right action jstor. What is michael slotes distinction between agentbased and. The term was coined by jeremy bentham in 1814, and he believed that deontology was a way to marshall selfinterested reasons for agents to act for the general good, but bentham believed that following a strict moral code of behavior was in fact for the general good of.
Virtue ethics in action introduction my plan is to begin by explaining virtue ethics in rather general terms, showing how its different from the two other main traditions in ethics. Consequentialist and nonconsequentialist ethics are both centered around the idea of judging actions. Agentbased virtue ethics avoids the circularity problem by defining right action. Applying virtue ethics to business the agent based approach. Solved virtue ethics virtue ethics is a broad term for. Michael slotes agentbased virtue ethics, according to which an action is right if and. Kantianism and utilitarianism, whereas virtue ethics concerns the aspirations of the agent. One of its chief proponents offers an agent based virtue ethical account that aspires to derive all moral value, including the moral status of actions, solely. Agentbased virtue ethics and the problem of action guidance. What determines ethical behavior in public organizations. Virtue ethics is the ideal ethical theory to use in this case, because it places the strongest focus on the moral quality of the person who is engaging in action. We note here that virtue ethics is an agentbased approach mingers and walsham, 2010 and that courage is a key organizational virtue necessary for innovation chatterjee et al.
He said that one needs to consider the inner life of an individual in order to evaluate right action. Pdf agentbased virtue ethics and the problem of action guidance. While traditional virtue ethics focused on the virtues, modern virtue ethics take on an agentbased approach where motives are the primary concern bessant 430. But, there are other approaches to morality as well. Virtue in epistemology in recent years virtue theory has not only undergone a resurgence in ethical thought, but has spilled over into other philosophical disciplines, most conspicuously epistemology. Journalquest is a free program to help academic student publications. Most virtue ethics theories take their inspiration. Abstract agent based virtue ethics is a unitary normative theory according to which the moral status of actions is entirely dependent upon the moral status of an agent s motives and character traits. An agentbased focus on what one ought to be, in contrast to an actionbased focus on how one ought to act, would look carefully at a persons moral. According to agent based approaches to virtue ethics, the rightness of an action is a function of the motives which prompted that action. Part of the ethics and political philosophy commons this dissertation is brought to you for free and open access by the walden dissertations and doctoral studies collection at scholarworks. Virtue ethics also does not provide guidance on how we should act, as there are no clear principles for guiding action other than act as a virtuous person would act given the situation.
One of the problems any such approach faces is to capture the commonsense distinction between an agents doing the right thing, and her doing it for the. Agent based virtue ethics strives to offer a viable account of both moral conduct and the source of moral value, independent of deontic teleological and deontological characterizations. Virtue ethics focus on the actor rather than on the action. In defence of agentbased virtue ethics research commons. Within business ethics there are three approaches which could be adopted. An agentbased theory emphasizes that virtues are determined by. It may, initially, be identified as the one that emphasizes the virtues, or moral character, in contrast to the approach that emphasizes duties or rules deontology or that emphasizes the consequences of actions consequentialism. The word deontology comes from the greek roots deon, which means duty, and logos, which means science. Keywords virtue ethics right action fully virtuous agent decent agent. Abstract agentbased virtue ethics is a unitary normative theory according to which the moral status of actions is entirely dependent upon the moral status of an agents motives and character traits. First, the problem moral schizophrenia poses, which most moral theories face.
Journal of moral philosophy journal of moral philosophy 6 2009 50 69. According to agentbased approaches to virtue ethics, the rightness of an action is a function of the motives which prompted that action. Management strategies for improving construction industry. Businesses are completely incompatible with virtue ethics essay sample. Ethics is a key component of good governance perry et al. One criticism that is frequently made focuses on the problem of guidance. Virtue ethics virtue ethics is a broad term for theories that emphasize the role of character and virtue in moral philosophy rather than either doing ones duty or acting in order to bring about good consequences. View agentbased virtue ethics research papers on academia.
Even many deontologists now stress the point that their actionguiding rules cannot, reliably. In the mid 1940s, innovative developments in science and philosophy led to the creation of a new branch of ethics that would later be called computer ethics or information ethics. Virtue, practical guidance, and practices open scholarship. Agent based virtue ethics and the problem of action guidance. Eudemonism is based in reasoning, agent based theories are based in common sense and intuition, and ethics of care is solely based on justice and it should be noted as a primarily feminist idea. If those motives were morally praiseworthy, then the. An action a is right for s in circumstances c if and only if a fully virtuous agent would characteristically do a in c. One, the agent based model of virtuous practi cal reasoning turns out to require precisely the sorts of deliberations that it professes to reject in the more aristotelian model. This can be seen through an evaluation of the current literature. Previous research has identified a number of factors that can shape standards of conduct within an organization, among which the role of leadership has attracted significant attention grojean et al. A more adequate approach to ethics, according to these ethicists, would take.
175 196 282 1329 335 104 921 85 1274 1407 1394 133 941 1482 296 511 797 1075 1161 40 423 825 471 1231 125 685 647 446 1320 1512 1197 494 97 151 59 711 1478 1448 54 908 538 433 1209